**

The culinary world is a battlefield of flavors, textures, and trends. What's hot one year can be passé the next, leaving chefs scrambling to stay ahead of the curve. But one ingredient, according to award-winning chef Jean-Pierre Dubois, is not only overrated but actively damaging the dining experience: fermented black garlic. In a recent interview, Dubois, known for his Michelin-starred restaurant in Lyon, France – often cited as the world’s best food city – lambasted the ingredient, calling its prevalence on menus a culinary crime. "It's invading menus!" he exclaimed.

The Fermented Black Garlic Frenzy: An Overrated Trend?

Fermented black garlic, created by heating whole bulbs of garlic for weeks, has experienced a meteoric rise in popularity. Its sweet, umami-rich flavor profile and supposed health benefits have made it a darling of chefs worldwide, appearing in everything from sauces and spreads to ice cream and cocktails. But Dubois isn't buying it. He argues that the intensely sweet flavor often overwhelms other, more delicate ingredients, resulting in a one-note, unbalanced dish.

"The problem isn't the taste itself," Dubois explains, "but its ubiquity. It's become a lazy shortcut, a way to add a perceived depth of flavor without genuine culinary skill. Many chefs use it to mask flaws in other ingredients or a lack of understanding of balanced seasoning."

Why Chefs Are Obsessed (and Why They Shouldn't Be)

The appeal of fermented black garlic is understandable. It's relatively easy to incorporate, possesses a unique flavor profile, and offers a perceived health halo. But this very accessibility, Dubois argues, contributes to its overuse.

• Ease of Use: Its intense flavor allows chefs to achieve a perceived complexity without requiring much effort in balancing flavors or developing sophisticated techniques.
• Health Halo: The purported health benefits, while not definitively proven, are a strong marketing tool, appealing to health-conscious diners.
• Trend Following: The bandwagon effect is powerful in the culinary world, and chefs often adopt trends without critically assessing their true merit.

Lyon: The World's Best Food City – A Bastion Against the Trend?

Dubois's critique comes from a place of authority. His restaurant, nestled in the heart of Lyon, consistently ranks amongst the world's best, placing Lyon itself firmly on the map as a culinary capital. Lyon, celebrated for its bouchons (traditional Lyonnaise restaurants) and its emphasis on fresh, seasonal ingredients, is often cited as the world's best food city. This title is earned through a dedication to traditional techniques, a deep understanding of flavor profiles, and a commitment to using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients. The city's culinary scene serves as a stark contrast to the trend-driven approaches of some other metropolitan areas.

The Lyonnaise Approach: A Masterclass in Culinary Balance

The culinary philosophy of Lyon values simplicity, balance, and an unwavering focus on the quality of the ingredients themselves. Unlike the tendency to rely on trendy ingredients to create excitement, Lyonnaise cuisine emphasizes the natural flavors of high-quality produce, meats, and cheeses. This philosophy, Dubois insists, is the key to creating truly memorable and exceptional dishes.

Beyond Black Garlic: The Bigger Picture of Culinary Trends

Dubois's criticism extends beyond fermented black garlic itself. He believes the broader trend of chasing fleeting culinary fads often overshadows the fundamental principles of good cooking:

• Emphasis on Technique: Mastering fundamental cooking techniques is essential for creating truly great food. Trends, he suggests, often distract from this core principle.
• Respect for Ingredients: Using high-quality, fresh ingredients is paramount. Relying on trend ingredients to mask poor quality is detrimental.
• Balance and Harmony: The art of cooking lies in the creation of balanced and harmonious flavor profiles. Overreliance on a single, dominant ingredient undermines this crucial aspect.

The Future of Fine Dining: A Return to Fundamentals?

Dubois's outspoken criticism highlights a growing concern within the culinary world: the overwhelming influence of trends over substance. He advocates for a return to the fundamentals of cooking – a focus on quality ingredients, masterful techniques, and a deep understanding of flavor balance. He hopes that chefs will prioritize substance over style, creating dishes that are both delicious and enduring, rather than chasing the next fleeting culinary craze. His call for a return to simplicity and fundamental principles might signal a shift away from the trend-driven landscape and back towards a celebration of culinary excellence, making Lyon's traditional approach more relevant than ever in the global food scene. Perhaps, in the end, the best food trend is a rejection of trends altogether.